| 
		
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 20Threads: 7
 Joined: Mar 2010
 
	
	
		Your drunk guitar teacher on stage begged me
 to watch over you
 in this jam-packed bolgia.
 
 Tobacco fog permeated the air.
 The fiends around us,
 in black shirts and tattered jeans,
 raised their pitchfork fingers
 as thunder broke out
 from their beer-reeked mouths.
 
 Your attention fixed on stage,
 listening to the noise of guitars
 screeching through the amplifiers,
 and cymbals crashing
 like shattered bottles on concrete.
 
 You were barely 16
 sipping your can of soda,
 exclaiming to me
 your view of anarchy.
 “Can you see it now?
 Amidst the chaos sprouts a rose!”
 
 Yet, all I saw
 was you.
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 805Threads: 374
 Joined: Dec 2009
 
	
	
		Very cool poem   . Just some of my thoughts.
  (03-22-2010, 06:26 PM)jdelacroix Wrote:  Remember the night I'm not sure it's necesary for you to frame the poem like this, with a reminiscing "Remember when..?" line; [you can keep it, but I think it's superfluous to the point of the poem, since you can tell the story well enough without it.you bore anarchy in my head?
 Your drunk guitar teacher
 on stage begged me
 to watch over you
 in that jam-packed bolgia.
 
 The tobacco fog permeated the air.
 The fiends around us,
 in black shirts and tattered jeans,
 raised their pitchfork fingers:
 in the name of sex, drugs and rock n’ roll. I think since the piece is alreadyt titled Rock Show, this line comes off as a little obvious. Replace it with a more unique line.
 
 Yet,
 your heart lingered  maybe 'lingered' isn't the word you meant; I know linger means to stay, so I don't quite understand what this means
 at the noise: of guitars
 screeching from the amplifiers,
 and cymbals crashing
 like shattered bottles
 on concrete.
 
 You were barely 16
 sipping your can of soda,
 exclaiming to me
 your view of anarchy.
 “Can you see it now?
 Amidst the chaos sprouts a rose!”
 
 I stood still. not the strongest line for me, not sure why. I think it's because I had no idea what you were actually doing before she stunned you to silence. Were you dancing or thrashing? Were you even standing?If I imagined in my head that you were already standing still then the line doesn't have the same impact.
 All I saw was you.
 
You'll have to wait for Billy's critique. He's on a trrip right now and it'll take a while for him to get on a computer again     
Overall nice job!
	
PS. If you can, try your hand at giving some of the others a bit of feedback. If you already have, thanks, can you do some more?
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 20Threads: 7
 Joined: Mar 2010
 
	
	
		 (03-23-2010, 10:21 AM)addy Wrote:  Very cool poem  . Just some of my thoughts. 
 
  (03-22-2010, 06:26 PM)jdelacroix Wrote:  Remember the night I'm not sure it's necesary for you to frame the poem like this, with a reminiscing "Remember when..?" line; [you can keep it, but I think it's superfluous to the point of the poem, since you can tell the story well enough without it.you bore anarchy in my head?
 Your drunk guitar teacher
 on stage begged me
 to watch over you
 in that jam-packed bolgia.
 
 The tobacco fog permeated the air.
 The fiends around us,
 in black shirts and tattered jeans,
 raised their pitchfork fingers:
 in the name of sex, drugs and rock n’ roll. I think since the piece is alreadyt titled Rock Show, this line comes off as a little obvious. Replace it with a more unique line.
 
 Yet,
 your heart lingered  maybe 'lingered' isn't the word you meant; I know linger means to stay, so I don't quite understand what this means
 at the noise: of guitars
 screeching from the amplifiers,
 and cymbals crashing
 like shattered bottles
 on concrete.
 
 You were barely 16
 sipping your can of soda,
 exclaiming to me
 your view of anarchy.
 “Can you see it now?
 Amidst the chaos sprouts a rose!”
 
 I stood still. not the strongest line for me, not sure why. I think it's because I had no idea what you were actually doing before she stunned you to silence. Were you dancing or thrashing? Were you even standing?If I imagined in my head that you were already standing still then the line doesn't have the same impact.
 All I saw was you.
 You'll have to wait for Billy's critique. He's on a trrip right now and it'll take a while for him to get on a computer again
  
 Overall nice job!
 
Hey Addy!    Thanks 4 d the critique. Told ya I wasn't sure with this one hahahaha. Anyways I'll edit and wait 4 billy's return some other time. Im working   (
	 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 5,057Threads: 1,075
 Joined: Dec 2009
 
	
		
		
		03-23-2010, 11:52 PM 
(This post was last modified: 03-23-2010, 11:55 PM by billy.)
	
	 
		 (03-22-2010, 06:26 PM)jdelacroix Wrote:  Remember the night is this line needed?you bore anarchy in my head?
 Your drunk guitar teacher
 on stage begged me
 to watch over you
 in that jam-packed bolgia.  five good lines
 
 The tobacco fog permeated the air.  is THE needed?
 The fiends around us,
 in black shirts and tattered jeans,
 raised their pitchfork fingers:
 in the name of sex, drugs and rock n’ roll. another good stanza though sd&r&r is cliche. oplay around with it a bit
 
 Yet,   is YET needed
 your heart lingered  pounded, rattled or something other than lingered
 at the noise: of guitars either lose the : or OF
 screeching from the amplifiers,  through instead of from maybe?
 and cymbals crashing
 like shattered bottles
 on concrete.  this stanza needs a bit of clarity for me
 
 You were barely 16
 sipping your can of soda,
 exclaiming to me
 your view of anarchy.
 “Can you see it now?
 Amidst the chaos sprouts a rose!”  i had to read this stanza twice but it works.
 
 I stood still.  is this line needed?
 All I saw was you.
 
 Quite honestly, I'm not sure with this one. Then again, I'm not always sure of my poems
  
all in all a good effort. all it needs is a small edit to make a big improvement. 
some good original lines and one big fat cliche    the sex drugs and rock and roll is the one i'm talking about  one way to convert the cliche is to openly call it cliched as in:
 
raised their pitchfork fingers:  
in the cliched name of sex, 
drugs and rock n’ roll.
 
the title leaves me a little flat. 
the rock show; sounds like a geological convention. 
try and lift it by hooking it into the poem or the poem into it.
 
thanks for the read jd.
 
if you post any more i'll reply as i get to them 
 
sorry if i'm a bit late though as i'm spending time with my kids in the uk
	 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 20Threads: 7
 Joined: Mar 2010
 
	
	
		 (03-23-2010, 11:52 PM)billy Wrote:   (03-22-2010, 06:26 PM)jdelacroix Wrote:  Remember the night is this line needed?you bore anarchy in my head?
 Your drunk guitar teacher
 on stage begged me
 to watch over you
 in that jam-packed bolgia.  five good lines
 
 The tobacco fog permeated the air.  is THE needed?
 The fiends around us,
 in black shirts and tattered jeans,
 raised their pitchfork fingers:
 in the name of sex, drugs and rock n’ roll. another good stanza though sd&r&r is cliche. oplay around with it a bit
 
 Yet,   is YET needed
 your heart lingered  pounded, rattled or something other than lingered
 at the noise: of guitars either lose the : or OF
 screeching from the amplifiers,  through instead of from maybe?
 and cymbals crashing
 like shattered bottles
 on concrete.  this stanza needs a bit of clarity for me
 
 You were barely 16
 sipping your can of soda,
 exclaiming to me
 your view of anarchy.
 “Can you see it now?
 Amidst the chaos sprouts a rose!”  i had to read this stanza twice but it works.
 
 I stood still.  is this line needed?
 All I saw was you.
 
 Quite honestly, I'm not sure with this one. Then again, I'm not always sure of my poems
  all in all a good effort. all it needs is a small edit to make a big improvement.
 some good original lines and one big fat cliche
  the sex drugs and rock and roll is the one i'm talking about  one way to convert the cliche is to openly call it cliched as in: 
 raised their pitchfork fingers:
 in the cliched name of sex,
 drugs and rock n’ roll.
 
 the title leaves me a little flat.
 the rock show; sounds like a geological convention.
 try and lift it by hooking it into the poem or the poem into it.
 
 thanks for the read jd.
 
 if you post any more i'll reply as i get to them
 
 sorry if i'm a bit late though as i'm spending time with my kids in the uk
 
thanks Bill    not only the s,d&rnr's cliche its sort of redundant to the title    hahahahaha
	 
		
	 
	
	
		This poem is so meaningful and from Bottom of my heart I am saying that I liked this Poem so much and really, I appreciate your thought.
	 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 20Threads: 7
 Joined: Mar 2010
 
	
	
		 (03-24-2010, 06:46 PM)alexjems41 Wrote:  This poem is so meaningful and from Bottom of my heart I am saying that I liked this Poem so much and really, I appreciate your thought. 
thanks alexjems ^_^
	 
		
	 |