Untitled ("Forty light years away ...")
#1
Forty light-years away, 
the stars watch me write words like
Starry night
or Thundering Love  
until I discover the tickle of writing
Velvet Voice of Venus.

They don't know 
that now I write 
Whispering together, trying to ignore the star-gazers
or The taste of wine in a shivering glass
and, like Zeno, have almost mastered the word
Love.

Why then do I shiver when the spark-sized
memory of that cold night 
forty light-years away 
whispers back at me, not yet heard, 
Starry night?
Reply
#2
(11-17-2026, 05:24 AM)purplie Wrote:  Forty light-years away, 
the stars watch me write words like  ironically, too many words here
Starry night
or Thundering Love  
until I discover the tickle of writing   Not a fan of 'tickle'.  A little too playful given my interpretation of the surrounding tone
Velvet Voice of Venus.

They don't know 
that now I write 
Whispering together, trying to ignore the star-gazers
or The taste of wine in a shivering glass   not sure what 'shivering' is trying to do here.  seems like a filler word trying to be interesting but is just the first word that occurred to the writer
and, like Zeno, have almost mastered the word  I like the reference to Zeno, but I think it would land better if the following phrase more directly related to Zeno than 'mastered'
Love.

Why then do I shiver when the spark-sized   too close to shivering
memory of that cold night     this line is expected to do too much work without enough supporting context, IMO
forty light-years away 
whispers back at me, not yet heard, 
Starry night?    the emotional significance of this phrase is unclear to me
Hi Purplie,
I noticed that you have already made some edits.  The formatting change was good in general but it might be better to put the italicized portions in quotes instead to distinguish it better.  I find it hard to see the distinction as written.  I don't like most of the other changes.  They push the poem too far into the whinging category for me without enough context for me to care.  Getting a good title might help with that without having to expand the body of the poem much.  Although, I think there needs to be some strategic word choice done to help the reader go down the desired path or at least move from annoying confusion to some thought provoking ambiguity.

One last house keeping suggestion.  It would be helpful to have the original available to refer to and is generally recommended to not delete earlier versions.  You can hide previous versions within a clickable tab below the edit using the (shit, I don't know what it's called), [=pre verse] text here [=/pre verse] except leave out the equal signs.  I just put them in there so you could see the code.  It looks like this when you do that:

Isn't this cool!?

Hope my comment are useful.
Take care,
Bryn
Reply
#3
(11-17-2026, 05:24 AM)purplie Wrote:  Forty light-years away, 
the stars watch me write words like
Starry night Would move "like" to here.
or Thundering Love  
until I discover the tickle of writing
Velvet Voice of Venus. The alliteration makes this line feel cheap.

They don't know 
that now I write Technically what stars see from forty light-years away is whatever happened forty years ago. So we can assume a fairly old speaker.
Whispering together, trying to ignore the star-gazers
or The taste of wine in a shivering glass Not as limpid of a line as the one before.
and, like Zeno, have almost mastered the word Which Zeno? I really don't know, and it might help specifying, making it clear if this is ironic (per Zeno with the paradoxes), anally retentive (per Zeno of stoicism), or theological (per the various saints named Zeno).
Love. Comment on the last line said, I don't think the examples cited in this stanza are smart enough to show mastery of any sort, not least "Love"---indeed, per the earlier commentator, maybe something other than "mastered" is here required.

Why then do I shiver when the spark-sized
memory of that cold night Would not "cold night" be redundant with "shiver"? 
forty light-years away 
whispers back at me, not yet heard, 
Starry night? This is a fine-ish ending overall. I think there could be a stronger phrase here than "Starry night", especially when the phrase typically refers to the Van Gogh painting, and I don't see any shades of Van Gogh here at all.

Also, this should probably have a title---I don't think this is strong enough yet to go without one.
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!