(6 hours ago)busker Wrote: (10 hours ago)matsunosuperfan Wrote: It's so vague and generallllll how am I meant to feel anything real
It's not that I don't believe or trust the speaker, I do
But they aren't giving me much access to the source of their emotion
There are poems about gangrene and gas-fitting, and there are lyrics. Not sure why the latter would aspire to the kind of specificity you're referring to.
Fair and I take your point. I think the answer is mostly "so it doesn't sound like a hollow also-ran in the romantic lyric tradition" which is mostly what we're getting here right now.
(1 hour ago)matsunosuperfan Wrote: (6 hours ago)busker Wrote: (10 hours ago)matsunosuperfan Wrote: It's so vague and generallllll how am I meant to feel anything real
It's not that I don't believe or trust the speaker, I do
But they aren't giving me much access to the source of their emotion
There are poems about gangrene and gas-fitting, and there are lyrics. Not sure why the latter would aspire to the kind of specificity you're referring to.
Fair and I take your point. I think the answer is mostly "so it doesn't sound like a hollow also-ran in the romantic lyric tradition" which is mostly what we're getting here right now.
songe
Dearest, my poems
that were wasted on you
weren’t wasted. Compelling opener
It’s true very disappointing first rhyme that kinda tells the story in a nutshell of what comes next
that life bitter tasted, gross! Clunky, why-he-do-that-mama? inversion; cut or fix
not apples and cherries, okay I guess, sure those things are not generally bitter
but berries of yew, I'm done with this boring pretentious speaker around here
but love is not wasted, straight cliche...
and that much is true. ...and acknowledging the fact implicitly doesn't save it
That time is not wasted
and youth is not wasted
and life is not wasted
in loving, they knew, fully a waste of a stanza
all lovers through the ages
and poets through the ages,
the sages and mages,
and so I loved you. prosaic and flat ending that sounds, tbh, completely derivative of Shakespeare and the like
I've never seen you post anything so empty and formally uninspired here
suggest reading someone risk-taking and aggressively creative for inspiration. Have you heard of Anne Carson?