LPiA-26 Nov. 14
#7
Thanks for commenting! 
Agree with all points there. The backstory connecting to the prompt was forced. And you’re right. Two poems are competing for space here. I like the first one best. 

Maybe I’ll put a revision I’ve been tinkering with in another forum and see what happens. Would love your opinion on future version. Thanks again for your input! 
(Yesterday, 09:23 AM)matsunosuperfan Wrote:  
(Yesterday, 06:54 AM)Naish Wrote:  Uncle LaFarr

The night I sat with Farr,

I held his straw,

decided when to push 
the morphine.


Had I known about ketamine then,

we might have died a little first.

I'm not afraid of death now,

but we were that night.

My grandpa's cousin, Farr

scored big in software, 
moved to San Jose.

He'd come alone at Christmas.


We'd get compasses, 
or hiking socks.

One year, headlamps.

At the end, he chose a park model
in Quartzsite, ‘till he got sick

and moved in with my mother.
He never meant to start a feud,

but he left it all to her.
 
Then she cut out her sister,

expecting me to side with her
and call it righteous.

Now they fight.

Heavy and full of impact. the "headlamps" stanza really feels like it's begging for one more line, to me. Something to add a tangent or complication or extention to make use of those suggestive images. 

I resist the break on "Farr" which creates, for me, too strong a caesura. It also made me briefly nervous that we were backing up for more context setting - actually, that is what happens. I question this decision once the poem has already started picking up steam. It is a bit prosaic. I don't see what it does for my experience of the poem to know that Farr scored in software, moved to San Jose, or came alone at Christmas. the implications, if there are any, are too faint to feel worthwhile. 

The previous stanza, about death, is really strong. I don't really have any notes there. As a result the drop in temperature with "here's some more Farr backstory" was too much for me. I was disappointed! You hooked me and then cut for a commercial break. 

Ending feels very skillful and sharp, but I don't really know how to feel about it. The poem feels just a bit too scattered right now, I would love it to cohere a bit more pointedly. Still, it's a very effective and affective account that I enjoyed reading. Thanks for sharing it here.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by Tiger the Lion - 11-14-2026, 09:26 AM
RE: LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by CRNDLSM - 11-14-2026, 10:53 AM
RE: LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by dukealien - Yesterday, 01:25 AM
RE: LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by Naish - Yesterday, 06:54 AM
RE: LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by matsunosuperfan - Yesterday, 09:23 AM
RE: LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by Naish - Yesterday, 07:46 PM
RE: LPiA-26 Nov. 14 - by RiverNotch - Yesterday, 11:32 AM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!