Untitled but seeking critique
#1
audiobook 
Hello.

Here is one I have just finished, looking for some feedback and how to improve it. 

Thank you to all who read it. 

----





When the rain falls, 
is it comfort or calamity to be quenched in a soggy skirt? 
My red highlights glistening amongst the green,
tantalizing all the forest. 


Yet my bark skin desires no bite. 


When the sunbeams pass through the foliage, 
I turn my face upward, 
smiling at mother nature’s garden. 


A songbird sings, 
I am its humble abode, 
offering up the sweetest melodies at the 1st of each month.
As if payment were required. 


A skeleton rests under me. 
Marked by a tombstone & periodic flowers fed by the teardrops from the anguish of the never-ending why…
Mothers all have that why. 


A whistle dances in the wind,
The silhouette of a brute follows its pulse to me. 
I see “RUFUS” etched into a sleeveless black and blue tartan. 
His arms are lined with scars. 


I shiver under his calloused hands as they pin a band beneath my breast. 
The wannabe Paul Bunyon plants a platypus kiss on my skin and speaks—



Mmm, special one. You ain’t like the others. 


His disgusting summer teeth grinned and a flare flickered in his chest. Lub-dub
His eyes catch mine drifting to his wasteland of scars rising up. 
He grins proudly,
As if they were the bones of a phoenix rising from the ash. 


Oh you will be sweet. So sweet. 


He shows me his hands, 
These were from a beautiful southern belle. 
She cried to God–digging her nails into my hands as I took her down. 
I keep her now as a treasure chest,
Her flashy bouquets spilling sweetness, 
Constantly reminding me of that hot summer night. 
Her name was Magnolia. 
The flare flickers.
Lub-dub, lub-dub.



He lifts up his neck,
This was from a luscious cut-throat bitch who wouldn’t stop screaming for her lover. 
She tried to strangle me. 
Little did she know her kinks were mine. 
I wear her now as a choker,
Proclaiming to all the world my openness. 
Her name was Ivy. 
The flare flickers. 
Lub-dub, lub-dub, lub-dub. 


He shows me his arms,
These were from a loony who thought she was a witch. 
She whipped me with her hair as I contorted her to my will.
Crying incantations to summon Lucifer to save her. 
I skinned her into a flute,
And whistle her weeping tune to lure. 
Her name was Willow. 


The fire blazes. 
Lub-dub, lub-dub, lub, dub, lub-dub. 


In that moment, 
I learned how forest fires roar.
I heard the cries of ancient girlhood ring through each and every one of his scars, 
Their smoke rising, 
casting a spell-binding circle.  


I am glad you came to me. 
For I have been waiting you see. 


Out of the ash
I rise with my red hair
And I eat men like air


My name is Sylvia.
Reply
#2
This might be a thornbush for me.

This poem sucks and I hate it, but it’s also wonderful and I love it.

It belongs in basic.

That’s not because it’s basic, it’s because it needs hammering, not chiseling.

If I had my way, I’d like this posted in basic in three chunks. Post a chunk, get it better, post the next chunk, get it better, etc. That should take four months. Then publish the whole aggressive weird imagistic noble nightmare all at once in serious. We’ll make a day of it. Slyvia Day.

There’s a good poem here. It’s keen and interesting and awake.

This stanza,

“When the rain falls,
is it comfort or calamity to be quenched in a soggy skirt?
My red highlights glistening amongst the green,
tantalizing all the forest.”

Is good.

But it’s also purple prose desperate to escape junior high English, and it hardly makes sense.

But it’s good.

Stay with us. Making this poem good is what we do.

Repost the first two stanzas in basic.
A yak is normal.
Reply
#3
(07-16-2024, 09:53 PM)crow Wrote:  This might be a thornbush for me.

This poem sucks and I hate it, but it’s also wonderful and I love it.

It belongs in basic.

That’s not because it’s basic, it’s because it needs hammering, not chiseling.

If I had my way, I’d like this posted in basic in three chunks. Post a chunk, get it better, post the next chunk, get it better, etc. That should take four months. Then publish the whole aggressive weird imagistic noble nightmare all at once in serious. We’ll make a day of it. Slyvia Day.

There’s a good poem here. It’s keen and interesting and awake.

This stanza,

“When the rain falls,
is it comfort or calamity to be quenched in a soggy skirt?
My red highlights glistening amongst the green,
tantalizing all the forest.”

Is good.

But it’s also purple prose desperate to escape junior high English, and it hardly makes sense.

But it’s good.

Stay with us. Making this poem good is what we do.

Repost the first two stanzas in basic.

Thank you for taking the time to read it and offer the critique. I agree with everything you said. I will repost it and do some editing prior to and send it off to basic where hopefully I can re-work it some more. I also made a horrific mistake with the ending writing Slyvia and it should be Sylvia. Thank you for not acknowledging this. 

Also, prior to your comment I'd never even heard of purple prose--so thank you for the education. I couldn't agree more, I want it to be readable for all but also don't aspire to junior high writing. I will stay with you and we will get there eventually fighting it out one line at a time crow.
Reply
#4
(Don’t re-post. Just tell me where you want it and I’ll move it for you. We prefer not to have multiple threads posted of the same poem. If you want to split the difference, you could put it in moderate. Basic critique doesn’t usually go very in-depth. Moderate allows more flexibility in either direction. It’s completely up to you, just let me know via pm.)

—Quix/admin
The Soufflé isn’t the soufflé; the soufflé is the recipe. --Clara 
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!