Posts: 4
	Threads: 5
	Joined: Dec 2024
	
	
 
	
	
		Edit 1:
I don't quite like
what poets say when
I put mustard on-my hot dog.
Their poems make a noise like
the bottle does ('fthplffthhhhth')
but are much less discreet.
(at   least
                     you
              don't have     to
   s h    a  k    e
                them quite   as hard
           to
         get anything
                to
              come
               out)
Original:
I don't very much like
what poems say when
I put mustard on-my hot dog.
They make a noise like
the bottle does ('fthplffthhhhth')
but are much less discreet.
(at   least
                     you
              don't have     to
   s h    a  k    e
                them quite
          as
                  hard      to
        get anything
                to
              come
               out)
	
	
	
	
		
	
 
 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 952
	Threads: 225
	Joined: Aug 2016
	
	
 
	
	
		I throughly enjoy the piece, especially the shake up towards the end, I dont quite get the first three lines though, 
'I don't very much like what poems say when I put mustard on my hot dog' 
while I don't mind surrealism, I think this could read clearer without ruining the lines.
Is the dash suppose to be between on and my? Said as one word 'onmy' or two separate phrases, I put mustard on: my hot dog.
	
	
	
Peanut butter honey banana sandwiches
	
		
	
 
 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 399
	Threads: 58
	Joined: May 2022
	
	
 
	
		
		
		12-04-2024, 10:21 AM 
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2024, 12:43 PM by brynmawr1.)
	
	 
	
		 (12-04-2024, 08:10 AM)spencedude75 Wrote:  I don't very much like   with kindness I say, Yoda speak it is.  Seriously, I think cutting the 'very much' works just fine. Or just use normal syntax
what poems say when   move 'when' to next line
I put mustard on-my hot dog.  Consider...when I put my mustard on.  cutting the hot dog part
They make a noise like  Poems    best to avoid pronouns when possible
the bottle does ('fthplffthhhhth')
but are much less discreet.
Poems make a noise,
('fthplffthhhhth'),
like the bottle does
but much less discreet.
(at   least     good slant rhyme 
                     you   good separation to emphasize the turn but not without problems
              don't have     to
   s h    a  k    e   like the form for function here
                them quite  these next lines could be compressed, and I think more effective.  Here the ambiguity of 'them' works
          as
                  hard      to
        get anything
                to
              come
               out)
eg...them quite as hard
to get anything...   using whatever white space you find satisfying
Hey SD75,
Welcome to the Pen.  Kudos to you for following the rules and actually providing a critique before posting.  I enjoyed the first two stanza very much, very original IMO.  That's not to say the rest isn't good just not as for me.  The turn gets a little obscure, meaning there is some abruptness of the new 'you', which I don't mind but then nothing that clarifies.  My take is this a nice masturbation poem, with a partner  

 , or 'you' is just a better poet or just better with condiments.  The solutions vary depending on your intent.
Well that's all I got for now.
Take care,
Bryn