| 
		
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 845Threads: 57
 Joined: Aug 2013
 
	
	
		final?
 Acer Aspiration
 
 Standing off-center
 in one loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a young maple waves her leafy hands.
 She's encircled by vulcanized road vipers
 stinking of sulfur and petrol. Undaunted,
 she flourishes triumphantly
 over rubber and rubble.
 
 The sapling yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust that twirls sugary straws
 pursued by a veil of eager flies.
 She's nearly invisible in the whirlwind,
 if not for her ruby autumn foliage
 contrasting the dull granite shards
 threatening her tender roots.
 
 Most motorists don’t notice
 this miracle or appreciate that in decades
 she’ll donate gallons of her sap
 just to provide enough syrup
 for their morning waffle.
 
 ---------------------------------------
 Dale/bena/ella edit 2, thanks
 
 Acer Aspiration
 
 Standing off-center
 in one loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a young maple waves her leafy hands.
 She's encircled by vulcanized road vipers
 stinking of sulfur and petrol. Undaunted,
 she flourishes triumphantly
 over rubber and rubble.
 
 The sapling yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust that twirls sugary straws
 pursued by a veil of eager flies.
 She's nearly invisible in the whirlwind,
 if not for her ruby autumn foliage
 contrasting the dull granite shards
 threatening her tender roots.
 
 Most motorists don’t notice
 this miracle or appreciate that in decades
 she’ll donate gallons of her sap
 just to provide enough syrup
 for their morning waffle.
 
 
 --------------------------------------
 Dale/bena edit 1 thank you
 
 Acer Aspiration
 
 Standing off-center
 in one loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a young maple waves her leafy hands.
 She's encircled by vulcanized road vipers.
 Undaunted, she flourishes triumphantly
 over rubber and rubble.
 
 The sapling yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust that twirls sugary straws
 pursued by fervent flies.
 She's nearly invisible in the whirlwind,
 if not for her ruby autumn foliage
 contrasting the dull granite shards
 threatening her tender roots.
 
 Motorists won’t notice this miracle
 of survival or realize the decades
 it will take her to mature
 or appreciate that she’ll donate
 two gallons of her sap
 to provide just enough syrup
 for their morning waffles.
 
 -----------------------------------
 Acer Aspirations
 
 Standing off center
 in the loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands.
 She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked,
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 
My new watercolor: 'Nightmare After Christmas'/Chris
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 1,827Threads: 305
 Joined: Dec 2016
 
	
	
		 (05-15-2014, 11:10 PM)ChristopherSea Wrote:  Acer Aspirations* "Overlooked, if not for her ruby foliage
 Standing off center
 in the loop of a cloverleaf ,<"A loop" unless this is the only one>
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands.
 She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked, < Will give alternate below*>
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 which contrasts with the dull granite stones
 laying about her tender roots.
 
 
_________________________________________________________ 
Chris,
 
I'm wondering if you would not be best to start a new stanza with "It's doubtful". I don't feel like the enjambment is particularly beneficial as it is so overtly obvious. I literally stopped reading when I came to that point because it stuck out so much.   
 
I am ambivalent about the last stanza. It almost seems to diminish the tree, rather than the opposite. Maybe:
 
"It's doubtful that anyone  
will notice this marvel  
of survival, or realize  
that one day her sap  
will provide sweet syrup; 
a counterpoint to her  
bitter upbringing."
  
This poem has a lot of potential. I like how you personify the tree as her. It ties in her syrup to the milk produced by mammals, and despite her harsh treatment, she grows into something that will give a present to those who ignore and treat her with neglect. I like the leafy hands image, but I would stay away from emphasizing the "maple leaf" aspect, as that carries much connotative baggage. 
 
Luck on your next edit (as you say),
 
Oh yeah, almost forgot. The title is cute as well as alliterative.  
 
Dale
	 
How long after picking up the brush, the first masterpiece?
 The goal is not to obfuscate that which is clear, but make clear that which isn't.
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 845Threads: 57
 Joined: Aug 2013
 
	
	
		 (05-16-2014, 02:58 AM)Erthona Wrote:  Dale, thank you for the thorough analysis and well thought out recommendations for this poem. (05-15-2014, 11:10 PM)ChristopherSea Wrote:  Acer Aspirations
 Standing off center
 in the loop of a cloverleaf ,<"A loop" unless this is the only one>
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands.
 She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked, < Will give alternate below*>
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 * "Overlooked, if not for her ruby foliage
 which contrasts with the dull granite stones
 laying about her tender roots.
 
 _________________________________________________________
 Chris,
 
 I'm wondering if you would not be best to start a new stanza with "It's doubtful". I don't feel like the enjambment is particularly beneficial as it is so overtly obvious. I literally stopped reading when I came to that point because it stuck out so much.
 
 I am ambivalent about the last stanza. It almost seems to diminish the tree, rather than the opposite. Maybe:
 
 "It's doubtful that anyone
 will notice this marvel
 of survival, or realize
 that one day her sap
 will provide sweet syrup;
 a counterpoint to her
 bitter upbringing."
 
 This poem has a lot of potential. I like how you personify the tree as her. It ties in her syrup to the milk produced by mammals, and despite her harsh treatment, she grows into something that will give a present to those who ignore and treat her with neglect. I like the leafy hands image, but I would stay away from emphasizing the "maple leaf" aspect, as that carries much connotative baggage.
 
 Luck on your next edit (as you say),
 
 Oh yeah, almost forgot. The title is cute as well as alliterative.
 
 Dale
  Many of those substitutions are right on. 
 One clarification, road vipers are a metaphor for cast off re-treads, not the roads themselves. I saw the image of these coiled nasties as quite menacing. I have a 'Ku' posted called 'Serpents of the Orbital' that inspired me to use them again. Southern truckers call them road gators. They create a hostile image and depict the daunting condition for this young tree.
 
 As for the ending, I am stressing the twenty year maturity time and the huge conversion factor of one gallon of sap to yield one tablespoon of syrup to suggest the arduous journey ahead of her, the 'aspiration' if you will. However, your suggestion of her nurturing us despite her treatment and neglect is a very intriguing take. I will think on both aspects. They may even work in combination. Much obliged./Chris
   
My new watercolor: 'Nightmare After Christmas'/Chris
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 294Threads: 4
 Joined: Sep 2013
 
	
	
		finally I catch something from the start where I can say something useful (hopefully)
 Acer Aspirations
 
 Standing off center ?
 in the loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands. 
She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked,
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 
 Really like most of this write, you have something good going with reminding us not to overlook the important things in life.
 
 love ya, \
 mel.
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 845Threads: 57
 Joined: Aug 2013
 
	
	
		 (05-16-2014, 05:21 AM)bena Wrote:  finally I catch something from the start where I can say something useful (hopefully)Some good ideas doll, glad to see you up and about. You always have something useful to say Melanie, thank you.
 Acer Aspirations
 
 Standing off center ?
 in the loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands. 
She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked,
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 
 Really like most of this write, you have something good going with reminding us not to overlook the important things in life.
 
 love ya, \
 mel.
 
 Off-center looks good to me.
 
 I think that I could have stretched more of that highway biome and hazard imagery across the first two stanzas to soften the blitz. Let me see what I can do with it.
 
 I'm glad you were routing for this little tree, I certainly am. I don't feel the ending marginalizes this sugar maple at all, but I think I see how another could see it that way. The intention was to illustrate how man does not appreciate the 'fruits of nature'.
 
 The maple's precious offering of syrup is the result of decades of growth and gallons of sap. This gift is renewable if done properly. I will definitely scrutinize my close.
 
 Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts and ideas on this one. Between the critiques from you and Dale, I have enough fro my next edit. Cheers xoxo/Chris
 
My new watercolor: 'Nightmare After Christmas'/Chris
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 57Threads: 11
 Joined: May 2014
 
	
	
		 (05-15-2014, 11:10 PM)ChristopherSea Wrote:  Dale/bena edit 1 thank you
 Acer Aspiration<-- what is the tree aspiring towards, or is the piece's aspiration for the tree?
 
 Standing off-center
 in one loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a young maple waves her leafy hands.
 She's encircled by vulcanized road vipers.
 Undaunted, she flourishes triumphantly
 over rubber and rubble.
 
 The sapling yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust that twirls sugary straws
 pursued by fervent flies.
 She's nearly invisible in the whirlwind,
 if not for her ruby autumn foliage
 contrasting the dull granite shards
 threatening her tender roots. <--not sure this is consistent with triumphantly
 
 Motorists won’t notice this miracle
 of survival or realize the decades
 it will take her to mature
 or appreciate that she’ll donate
 two gallons of her sap <-- does anyone tap trees in medians?
 to provide just enough syrup
 for their morning waffles.
 
 -----------------------------------
 Acer Aspirations
 
 Standing off center
 in the loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands.
 She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked,
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 
First thought: Harold and Maude. If you've seen it you know. I'm not sure if I understand the focus. On one hand there's the power of life to over come and find a way. On the other there's a lack of awareness by the motorists as they drive by, and then there's the carelessness of the planners who thought a narrow median (I'm guessing it's narrow) would be a perfect place for a tree. I'm not sure if it needs a specific focus, however  I would prefer it if the tree wasn't anthropomorphized. I don't think it adds anything to the piece.
	 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 845Threads: 57
 Joined: Aug 2013
 
	
	
		 (05-17-2014, 12:46 PM)bbcashdollar Wrote:  bbcd, Thanks for taking a look and sharing your reactions. The tree was not planned, but an accident/opportunity of nature. However, a cloverleaf loop is a large area (100s of square feet). I thought the plot and theme were self-evident.  I will take another close look nonetheless. Just surviving is triumphant. It's aspiration is survival, but the double entendre is welcomed. (05-15-2014, 11:10 PM)ChristopherSea Wrote:  Dale/bena edit 1 thank you
 Acer Aspiration<-- what is the tree aspiring towards, or is the piece's aspiration for the tree?
 
 Standing off-center
 in one loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a young maple waves her leafy hands.
 She's encircled by vulcanized road vipers.
 Undaunted, she flourishes triumphantly
 over rubber and rubble.
 
 The sapling yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust that twirls sugary straws
 pursued by fervent flies.
 She's nearly invisible in the whirlwind,
 if not for her ruby autumn foliage
 contrasting the dull granite shards
 threatening her tender roots. <--not sure this is consistent with triumphantly
 
 Motorists won’t notice this miracle
 of survival or realize the decades
 it will take her to mature
 or appreciate that she’ll donate
 two gallons of her sap <-- does anyone tap trees in medians?
 to provide just enough syrup
 for their morning waffles.
 
 -----------------------------------
 Acer Aspirations
 
 Standing off center
 in the loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands.
 She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked,
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 First thought: Harold and Maude. If you've seen it you know. I'm not sure if I understand the focus. On one hand there's the power of life to over come and find a way. On the other there's a lack of awareness by the motorists as they drive by, and then there's the carelessness of the planners who thought a narrow median (I'm guessing it's narrow) would be a perfect place for a tree. I'm not sure if it needs a specific focus, however  I would prefer it if the tree wasn't anthropomorphized. I don't think it adds anything to the piece.
 
 Primarily, the poem is about overcoming the odds and my respect for what nature offers us. It's at least 20 years of maturity and tens of gallons of sap to produce that little 6 oz bottle of maple syrup (whether you tap it or not, that amazing revelation stands). In the area of New England where I live many of the sugar maples are tapped.
 
 You probably have to be a tree-hugger to appreciate giving the tree an identity. However, I can care more about some trees that certain humans.
 
 Thanks again./Chris
 
My new watercolor: 'Nightmare After Christmas'/Chris
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 1,325Threads: 82
 Joined: Sep 2013
 
	
	
		Hi, Chris, I've been enjoying this and, as usual, you've done an effective edit. A few notes:  (05-15-2014, 11:10 PM)ChristopherSea Wrote:  Dale/bena edit 1 thank you
 Acer Aspiration
 
 Standing off-center
 in one loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a young maple waves her leafy hands. Clear image, I know that tree.
  She's encircled by vulcanized road vipers. Good change in position here, it works.
 Undaunted, she flourishes triumphantly
 over rubber and rubble. Nice sound and accurate description, well done.
 
 The sapling yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust that twirls sugary straws
 pursued by fervent flies. Fervent flies are a bit much for me after sugary straws.
 She's nearly invisible in the whirlwind,
 if not for her ruby autumn foliage
 contrasting the dull granite shards
 threatening her tender roots. Again, clear image and I can feel the sharpness.
 
 Motorists won’t notice this miracle
 of survival or realize the decades
 it will take her to mature
 or appreciate that she’ll donate
 two gallons of her sap
 to provide just enough syrup
 for their morning waffles.
 
 You noticed, so maybe "Most motorists don't notice this miracle."  I think "of survival or realize the decades it will take her to mature or" could be cut, I think the lines after it say this and say it in a more interesting way. I love the end.
 
 
 
 -----------------------------------
 Acer Aspirations
 
 Standing off center
 in the loop of a cloverleaf
 like a flagstick on a golf green,
 a sapling waves her maple leaf hands.
 She burgeons triumphantly,
 peering over rubber and rubble.
 
 She yields to a cyclone
 of car exhaust
 that whirls sugary straws
 pursued by eager flies. She's encircled
 by coiled road vipers,
 vulcanized serpents stinking
 of sulfur and petroleum.
 
 She might be overlooked,
 if not for the ruby foliage
 contrasting dull granite stones
 about her tender roots. It's doubtful
 that anyone will notice her,
 see this marvel of survival
 or realize that in two decades
 
 one gallon of her sap
 could provide enough syrup
 for one morning waffle.
 
Hope this helps, good work here.   
billy wrote:welcome to the site. make it your own, wear it like a well loved slipper and wear it out. ella pleads:please click forum titles for posting guidelines, important threads. New poet? Try Poetic DevicesandWard's Tips
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 845Threads: 57
 Joined: Aug 2013
 
	
	
		Yes, it does help, thanks so much Marcella. I was wondering if that double alliteration blitz would be too much, perhaps eager flies or a cloud of some sort would play out better. I see what you mean about the closing stanza. Some of that was built up to address some one else's concern. Let me see what I can do with it. Cheers/Chris
I have a new edit based on your suggestions. Much obliged.   
My new watercolor: 'Nightmare After Christmas'/Chris
 
		
	 
	
	
	
		
	Posts: 845Threads: 57
 Joined: Aug 2013
 
	
	
		Dale/bena/ella edit 2 is posted, thanks folks!
	 
My new watercolor: 'Nightmare After Christmas'/Chris
 
		
	 |