Too Restless to Sleep (Revision 5)
#21
Hey Todd,
I quite like what I'm seeing here. I'll go into more detail below:

(10-19-2017, 06:48 AM)Todd Wrote:  Revision 4

Bare of leaves, the wild oaks
stretch like fellow insomniacs. -I like this opening. It works with the title and makes me want to see where this poem is taking me.

Dew sizzles in beads
on the long grass. -Why is the grass long? It implies growth, which I think works with the idea of no sleep/rest. To me, this works with the title being "Too Restless to Sleep".

Under the dry light, flowers glint,-I noticed there has been some discussion about the use of the word "flowers". I like the use of "flowers" here because it made me think the speaker is talking about more than one type of flower. My impression could be wrong. It wouldn't be the first time.
unblown pinwheels in the thick air. 

I shift in the dirt 
from foot to foot, 

knowing the end
will be nothing like this. -I quite like the last two stanzas. It makes me think that in the end we will not be surrounded by life (i.e. oaks, grass, flowers). Is this a poetic way of saying we all die alone? Don't answer that question if it would give too much away about the poem.

Revision 3

Bare of leaves, the wild trees
stretch like fellow insomniacs.

Dew sizzles in beads
on the long grass.

Under the dry light, flowers glint
in the still air, unblown pinwheels. 

I shift in the dirt 
from foot to foot, 

knowing the end
will be nothing like this.


Revision 2

The wild trees, bare of leaves, 
seem like fellow insomniacs
under the dry light of the forest.

Flowers glint in the still air, 
unblown pinwheels
as dew sizzles on the long grass.

I shift in the dirt from foot to foot, 
knowing the end
will be nothing like this.

Revision

The wild trees, bare of leaves, 
seem like fellow insomniacs
under the dry light of the forest.

The flowers still in the heavy air, 
unblown, stationary pinwheels.

I shift in the dirt from foot to foot, 
knowing the end
will be nothing like this.


Original

Under the dry light of the forest,
flowers are unblown, stationary pinwheels.
 
The wild trees, bare of leaves,
seem like fellow insomniacs.
 
I stand in the dirt shifting 
from foot to foot,

knowing the end
will be nothing like this.
I hope I was helpful in what I said here because I feel like I might have just rambled a bit. I do feel like you're very close with this one.

Cheers,
Richard
Time is the best editor.
Reply
#22
Thanks Richard, this is one of those poems that my meaning unfolds to me more and more as the critiques come in. Some things are plotted out, some like this one are written from feel and discovered in revision.

So, I took some good things from your comments. Thanks,

Best,

Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#23
(10-19-2017, 06:48 AM)Todd Wrote:  Revision 4

Bare of leaves, the wild oaks                 maybe "the wild oaks stretch bare of leaves"/ like fellow insomniacs (to avoid the enjambment).    
stretch like fellow insomniacs.

Dew sizzles in beads                    together with the sizzling i thought of those sweet fizzy chains where you could chew off one bead by one ..time, telomeres..  don´t know if you meant something like that, quite like the meta anyway.
on the long grass.                                 

Under the dry light, flowers glint,           
unblown pinwheels in the thick air.              this line is in my op. almost too compressed and seems to me like a slightly different story.
another word for "unblown" might be more fitting since it seems to be more an impossibility to blow them in the thick air than a decision (forget all that if i understood it completely wrong)

I shift in the dirt
from foot to foot,       not sure if "from foot to foot" adds anything here that wasn´t in "shifting". i could imagine the two last stanzas compressed to one 3-liner.

knowing the end
will be nothing like this.    



the title pictures sleep as something desired,
while in your poem, especially the ending, sleep appears more like the proverbial little brother ..
maybe just name it "restless" ?
...
Reply
#24
Hi Christine, I missed seeing your comments from October. Thank you for them. I did a revision.

Best,

Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#25
(10-19-2017, 06:48 AM)Todd Wrote:  Revision 5

Bare of leaves, the wild oaks stretch
like fellow insomniacs.

Dew sizzles in beads
along the long grass.

Flowers glint under the dry light,
unblown pinwheels in thick air. 

I shift my feet in the dirt 
knowing the end

will be nothing like this.

i like the revision as i already liked the original, esp. L3. cool to read it again.
maybe a comma after "dirt".
...
Reply
#26
Hey Todd, I liked what you did with the ending. The extra emphasis placed on, "will be nothing like this" by your spacing change is completely justified.

Cheers,
Richard
Time is the best editor.
Reply
#27
Cristine & Richard, Thanks for the comments. Glad the revision is working. I'll take the note on the comma, Cristine.

Thank you,

Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply
#28
(10-19-2017, 06:48 AM)Todd Wrote:  Revision 5

Bare of leaves, the wild oaks stretch
like fellow insomniacs.

Dew sizzles in beads
along the long grass.

Flowers glint under the dry light,
unblown pinwheels in thick air. 

I shift my feet in the dirt, 
knowing the end

will be nothing like this.

Revision 4

Bare of leaves, the wild oaks
stretch like fellow insomniacs.

Dew sizzles in beads
on the long grass.

Under the dry light, flowers glint,
unblown pinwheels in the thick air. 

I shift in the dirt 
from foot to foot, 

knowing the end
will be nothing like this.

Revision 3

Bare of leaves, the wild trees
stretch like fellow insomniacs.

Dew sizzles in beads
on the long grass.

Under the dry light, flowers glint
in the still air, unblown pinwheels. 

I shift in the dirt 
from foot to foot, 

knowing the end
will be nothing like this.


Revision 2

The wild trees, bare of leaves, 
seem like fellow insomniacs
under the dry light of the forest.

Flowers glint in the still air, 
unblown pinwheels
as dew sizzles on the long grass.

I shift in the dirt from foot to foot, 
knowing the end
will be nothing like this.

Revision

The wild trees, bare of leaves, 
seem like fellow insomniacs
under the dry light of the forest.

The flowers still in the heavy air, 
unblown, stationary pinwheels.

I shift in the dirt from foot to foot, 
knowing the end
will be nothing like this.


Original

Under the dry light of the forest,
flowers are unblown, stationary pinwheels.
 
The wild trees, bare of leaves,
seem like fellow insomniacs.
 
I stand in the dirt shifting 
from foot to foot,

knowing the end
will be nothing like this.

I enjoyed this. Some thoughts:

Dew sizzles in beads
along the long grass.

Dew cannot sizzle as this brings up imagery of heat and the sun burns off dew before there is the possibility of it sizzling.

I felt that '''along" and "long" in the same line were unnecessarily awkward.

Flowers glint under the dry light,
unblown pinwheels in thick air. 

Glint makes me think metalic which contrasts with the flower analogy... But really liked the piece about pinwheels.

I shift my feet in the dirt, 
knowing the end

Why do you know? What about this poem conveys that the speaker has such knowledge?

Hope this feedback is helpful. Thanks for sharing!
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!