Overthought
#1
Hi! Long time no see. I haven't been here in a while, but I was hoping to get some critique/revision on this piece....  Im going to go read some of your pieces and share some thoughts! I hope you all have been well.

Overthought 

There will come a day
when life tires of you.
The great abandonment
that leaves you on the other side,
alone.

Go with your middle finger high,
cheeks pulled wide
as its back turns.

You prepared for this
through philosophers’ words,
dog-eared books and 
circled proverbs,
hours spent
trying to outthink
what would never spare you.

Aren’t you glad?
Reply
#2
(Yesterday, 08:43 AM)carahmellow Wrote:  Hi! Long time no see. I haven't been here in a while, but I was hoping to get some critique/revision on this piece....  Im going to go read some of your pieces and share some thoughts! I hope you all have been well.

Overthought 

There will come a day
when life tires of you.  Nicely reversed commonplace (vice tiring of life)  But punctuation (see below)
The great abandonment
that leaves you on the other side,
alone.

Go with your middle finger high,
cheeks pulled wide
as its back turns. As in, not only don't I need you, I never did.

You prepared for this
through philosophers’ words,
dog-eared books and 
circled proverbs,
hours spent
trying to outthink   more like unthink?
what would never spare you.

Aren’t you glad?   Oddly, yes (see below)

This bounces around a little, though the theme is constant.  One suggestion - the first stanza could (should?) be all one sentence with an em dash or colon after the first "you."

On a purely practical note, the posture advocated would be rather difficult unless one happens to have three hands.  Or places a severed social finger atop one's head?  (But seriously, the impossibility adds to the humor.  So stet.)

The irony/cynicism of the final question is, in fact, answered with equanimity if the philosophers you chose to read and circle were Stoics.  Or if you chose revealed religion instead of philosophy and contrived to die in the odor of sanctity.

But all these cavils aside, it's witty and well expressed.  The vulgarity is implied (which adds to the humor).  Good job.
feedback award Non-practicing atheist
Reply
#3
(Yesterday, 08:43 AM)carahmellow Wrote:  Hi! Long time no see. I haven't been here in a while, but I was hoping to get some critique/revision on this piece....  Im going to go read some of your pieces and share some thoughts! I hope you all have been well.

Overthought 

There will come a day
when life tires of you.
The great abandonment
that leaves you on the other side,
alone.

Go with your middle finger high,
cheeks pulled wide
as its back turns.

You prepared for this
through philosophers’ words,
dog-eared books and 
circled proverbs,
hours spent
trying to outthink
what would never spare you.

Aren’t you glad?

Just a couple of things: 
I'm not sure the last three lines of the first stanza add anything and may detract from that clever opening thought. 
You could add "then" to the second line of stanza 2 to avoid the need for the third hand.
Fun little poem, thanks for sharing.
Reply
#4
(Yesterday, 08:43 AM)carahmellow Wrote:  Hi! Long time no see. I haven't been here in a while, but I was hoping to get some critique/revision on this piece....  Im going to go read some of your pieces and share some thoughts! I hope you all have been well.

Overthought 

There will come a day
when life tires of you.
The great abandonment
that leaves you on the other side,
alone.

Go with your middle finger high,
cheeks pulled wide
as its back turns.

You prepared for this
through philosophers’ words,
dog-eared books and 
circled proverbs,
hours spent
trying to outthink
what would never spare you.

Aren’t you glad?

First couplet is too good. You set a really high bar and then kinda limbo under it for the rest of the poem. The tone and action of what follows is not particularly surprising or interesting to me, vulgarity and snark notwithstanding. I find the second stanza almost impossible to visualize. The title is flattening and kills the dynamic tension. Last 3ines of S1 and S3 are too explanatory and do a similar flattening. 

I think this could be a very good poem but you simply have to be more demanding and fight harder for sharp rhetoric. I think a piece like this will generally either be brilliant or mid with little in between. But yeah, killer first couplet.
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!